Can Porter Martone, Gavin McKenna work their way back into Calder conversation?

Going into the 2026-27 NHL campaign, both Gavin McKenna of the Toronto Maple Leafs and Porter Martone of the Philadelphia Flyers were expected to be at the front of the pack in the Calder Trophy race for rookie of the year.
But through the first quarter of the season, the two have faced their struggles, whether it’s a lack of production or ice time itself. Meanwhile, Montreal Canadiens goaltender Jacob Fowler has shown flashes of brilliance in his first full NHL season, leading the team with a 10-2-2 record and a .923 save percentage.
On Thursday’s episode of Daily Faceoff LIVE, Tyler Yaremchuk and former NHL goaltender Carter Hutton are joined by Daily Faceoff prospect analyst Steven Ellis to discuss the Calder race and if both Martone and McKenna are still in the hunt.
Carter Hutton: Two guys who had big expectations going into the year were Gavin McKenna and Porter Martone. They were the preseason favorites for the Calder Trophy. Can either of those two work their way back into the conversation with Jacob Fowler?
Steven Ellis: I think so, I think both should be in that conversation. There’s always these guys who kind of come out in the second half and really wake up, and I think you’re looking at Mortone for that one. He’s not producing at a high level; he had 10 points in his nine games last season, and right now he’s got nine points in 24 games in 2026-27. It feels like in Philadelphia, it’s been a tough watch this year.
Then you look at a guy like McKenna where there were some growing pains early on and now he’s starting to figure it out. When he’s hot, he can be the best rookie in this class. I think he finished October as the top-scoring rookie in the league, and that’s something where, again, at his best, you’re not going to find a guy who is more skilled.
That being said, we’ve seen his ice time bounce around a little bit, we’ve seen him play on the third line, we haven’t seen him play with guys like Auston Matthews consistently. It appears he got bumped up to the top power-play unit on Thursday, and that’s a good sign for him. But in general, I’m not worried about McKenna’s game: we’re talking about a guy who is going to put up points, but you’re probably going to need Fowler to fall off a cliff if he wants to win rookie of the year.
You can watch the full segment and the rest of the episode here…