Daily Faceoff is a news site with no direct affiliation to the NHL, or NHLPA

How much should team quality impact a goalie’s Vezina candidacy?

Tyler Kuehl
Nov 20, 2026, 18:00 EST

PuckPediaDaily Faceoff
How much should team quality impact a goalie’s Vezina candidacy?
Credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images

The process for determining who wins the Vezina Trophy as the NHL’s top goaltender has been heavily debated for eons.

Along with whether general managers should be the ones voting on the award, the criteria for what makes a goaltender the best in the league is another hot topic. For most of its history, goaltenders seemingly only qualify for the award if their team makes it to the Stanley Cup Playoffs, though Sergei Bobrovsky took home the honor on a Columbus Blue Jackets team that failed to make it to the postseason.

On Friday’s edition of Daily Faceoff LIVE, Tyler Yaremchuk and Carter Hutton discuss whether a goaltender is a true Vezina contender if the team in front of him is good.

Tyler Yaremchuk: [Pyotr] Kochetkov…not considered one of high-end goalies in the NHL. But these numbers are absolutely insane. But what a lot of people will say is, ‘Well, yeah, he plays on Carolina. That’s a team that limits chances and all this stuff.’ How much do you factor in the quality of the team in front of the goalie when kind of picking out and trying to pick your way through this Vezina conversation.

Carter Hutton: It’s not a non-factor, right? It’s something to go into that, but it’s also something you don’t control, too. There’s also times where there’s silence and you don’t get a lot of work, and you can stay busy and stay efficient. For Kochetkov, I think being in the situation that he was thrust into, where you know he kind of was on the outside looking in, having the record he has right now winning games, 12-1-1, like this has been a big factor.

I think what comes into play for me, is going to be games played. When you start to push those games played up for Kochetkov, is there sustainability? I think right now it just he’s been like outstanding, and I think it just adds to the strength of his character. I think being in a system where you’re expected to win, and he’s answering the call no matter what’s thrown at him each night.

You can watch the full segment and entire episode here…

PuckPediaDaily Faceoff