Daily Faceoff is a news site with no direct affiliation to the NHL, or NHLPA

Islanders’ Matthew Schaefer becomes third teenage NHL defender to record hat trick

Hunter Crowther
Nov 17, 2026, 22:53 EST

PuckPediaDaily Faceoff
Islanders’ Matthew Schaefer becomes third teenage NHL defender to record hat trick
Credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Matthew Schaefer can’t stop making history.

The New York Islanders’ defenseman scored a hat trick during the team’s 5-1 win over the Columbus Blue Jackets Tuesday night, becoming the third teenage defenseman in NHL history to record three goals in a game.

The other two teenage defenders to achieve the feat were Phil Housley and Hannu Virta, both with the Buffalo Sabres during the 1982-83 season.

Schaefer, 19, finished the night with three goals and nine shots in 23:23 of ice time. The Islanders are now 10-6-4 with 24 points this season.

Through 20 games in 2026-27, Schaefer has nine goals and 15 assists for 24 points, averaging 26:58 of ice time per game. The Hamilton, Ont., native has 32 goals and 51 assists for 83 points in 102 career NHL contests.

Schaefer is coming off one of the most impressive seasons for a rookie defenseman in NHL history. He finished with 23 goals and 36 assists for 59 points, averaged 24:41 of ice time per game, capped off by winning the 2026 Calder Trophy for rookie of the year.

His 23 goals placed him second among all NHL defenseman in 2025-26, behind only Jakob Chychrun of the Washington Capitals. He made NHL history by tying Hockey Hall of Famer Brian Leetch for the most goals by a rookie defender, and also became the youngest blueliner in NHL history to reach 50 points in a season.

Schaefer was selected by the Islanders with the No. 1 overall pick in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft, despite the fact he played just 73 career OHL regular-season games due to injuries. In parts of two seasons with the Erie Otters, the 6-foot-2 defender posted 10 goals and 29 assists for 39 points. 

PuckPediaDaily Faceoff