If the Leafs organization has any pride, Jim Hiller has to go

One. Point.
That’s what every moral victory, every “We’re right there,” every “step forward” has earned the Toronto Maple Leafs in eight games since Halloween. Seven of those eight games were played at home. And for the Leafs’ latest sad trick: they blew a 3-0 lead in the span of 12 spastic second-period minutes before falling to the Los Angeles Kings 4-3 in a shootout Thursday night.
If you’re the world’s biggest optimist, you could cling to a resurgent night from the briefly demoted William Nylander, which included a pair of nifty primary assists, as a positive. You could point out that goaltender Anthony Stolarz stopped an Alex Laferriere breakaway in the third period to usher the Leafs to overtime and help them salvage their first November point on the 19th day of the month.
But who are we kidding if we think that way?
“That’s a game we have to hold through and come out with two points,” said Leafs captain Auston Matthews. “It’s obviously very frustrating. It’s hard to lose, it’s hard to go on a stretch like this. And especially the last couple games where I thought we’d come out playing well and doing a lot of things, and then it just falls apart.”
A single point doesn’t drag the Leafs out of their bottomless pit. The players seem to know it. But does their coach know it?
The Leafs are 4-9-2 in their own building this season. During their eight-game losing streak, they’ve been outscored 33-15. Their last “victory” came against the Losin’ for Landon Vancouver Canucks, the NHL’s worst team, and the NHL’s second-worst team, the Chicago Blackhawks, blew them out earlier this week.
When we factor in that GM John Chayka built a more-or-less new roster that dressed 10 first-time Leafs on opening night and was seemingly engineered to show Matthews he could still win in Toronto: it isn’t hyperbole to call this stretch one of the most embarrassing in franchise history relative to the elevated expectations when the season began.
Not even the potential humiliation of dropping an eighth straight game was enough to stop Toronto from coughing up a three-goal lead – against a Kings team that ranks seventh in the Pacific Division and happens to be the club that fired Jim Hiller last season. There were seemingly infinite reasons to light a fire under the Leafs tonight. They still couldn’t muster a win.
Has this team’s pride evaporated?
“I don’t fear that. I don’t fear that,” Hiller told Daily Faceoff after Thursday’s game. “I thought that the overtime was extremely entertaining. I thought we had great chances, and we wouldn’t be talking about pride if one of those goes in.”
Hiller isn’t relenting. He isn’t letting the everything-is-fine façade drop. He isn’t throwing his players under the bus and breathing fire and saying he’s had it with his team’s effort. He’s a players’ coach. He doesn’t appear to have a boiling point in him. And it’s fair to wonder if he has the traits required to motivate his team.
It’s also fair to wonder if Hiller can tactically steer the Leafs out of their spin. He continues to make befuddling lineup decisions almost nightly. He “promoted” rookie and first overall pick Gavin McKenna to the second line and top power-play unit Thursday only to hand him 14:28 of ice time. McKenna now sits 15th among rookie NHL forwards this season in average TOI. In fact, he averages the fifth-fewest minutes of any rookie forward drafted first overall since the league began tracking ice time in 1997-98, and only two this century have averaged fewer minutes than McKenna:
| Player | Season | Average TOI |
| Joe Thornton | 1997-98 | 8:05 |
| Vincent Lecavalier | 1998-99 | 13:28 |
| Patrik Stefan | 1999-00 | 14:49 |
| Ilya Kovalchuk | 2001-02 | 18:32 |
| Rick Nash | 2002-03 | 13:57 |
| Alex Ovechkin | 2005-06 | 21:37 |
| Sidney Crosby | 2005-06 | 20:08 |
| Patrick Kane | 2007-08 | 18:22 |
| Steven Stamkos | 2008-09 | 14:56 |
| John Tavares | 2009-10 | 18:00 |
| Taylor Hall | 2010-11 | 18:13 |
| Ryan Nugent-Hopkins | 2011-12 | 17:36 |
| Nail Yakupov | 2012-13 | 14:34 |
| Nathan MacKinnon | 2013-14 | 17:21 |
| Connor McDavid | 2015-16 | 18:53 |
| Auston Matthews | 2016-17 | 17:38 |
| Nico Hischier | 2017-18 | 16:19 |
| Jack Hughes | 2019-20 | 15:52 |
| Alexis Lafreniere | 2020-21 | 13:53 |
| Juraj Slafkovsky | 2022-23 | 12:13 |
| Connor Bedard | 2023-24 | 19:47 |
| Macklin Celebrini | 2024-25 | 19:47 |
| Gavin McKenna | 2026-27 | 13:57 |
McKenna did not see a shift in the final 7:47 of regulation and, despite seemingly having a skill set tailored for 3-on-3 overtime and the shootout, didn’t touch the ice in either. And Hiller offered what has become a customary head-scratching explanation as to why.
“He’s watched. We’ve had him up and then called him off,” Hiller said. “He’ll get out there eventually. But it’s a high-leverage time. We need somebody to make a play. I just want to make sure, I just [don’t] want to put him in a spot that doesn’t go well.”
Doesn’t go well. Fair. Wouldn’t want anything to go wrong with McKenna out there, such as an eight-game losing streak. Can’t jeopardize that.
Hiller was an effective assistant coach in his first run with the Leafs as part of Mike Babcock’s staff from 2015-16 through 2018-19. He gave some grinding Kings groups enough structure to make them a consistent playoff team the past few seasons. His players seem to like him. But he’s overmatched and overwhelmed in his new job, period. It’s time for GM John Chayka and senior executive advisor Mats Sundin to admit they made a mistake.
Yes, firing Hiller would reflect poorly on them. But eight consecutive losses and seven straight in their own building transcends the management of the front office’s egos. It should also transcend any notion that the Leafs would be loath to pay three coaches at once, with Craig Berube still collecting pay stubs and a third coach needing a contract. If we are to believe MLSE president and CEO Keith Pelley’s constant proclamations that the team won’t tolerate a losing culture: prove it, Mr Pelley. This team could not have more of a losing culture. Worried about the money? Please. Paying three coaches is the equivalent of dropping coins in a mall Santa’s Salvation Army box for a corporation this wealthy.
If the Leafs still believe they have a genuine chance to make the playoffs this season, they should see if the Vegas Golden Knights would be wiling to unshackle Bruce Cassidy for an interview. They didn’t want to release him to a Pacific rival in the Edmonton Oilers, but they may not see the Leafs as the same kind of threat. Cassidy is a proven Stanley Cup winner, a well spoken man with the gravitas Hiller seems to lack in dealing with the Toronto media and, unlike Berube’s, Cassidy’s teams historically drive the play and possess the puck a lot.
That said: it’s possible the Leafs are too far gone already to worry about a win-now coaching change. American Thanksgiving arrives next week, and more than 75 percent of playoff spots are locked in on average by this juncture of the season. Per Money Puck, Toronto’s playoff chances are down to 1.3 percent, the fourth-lowest in the NHL. They simply might not represent an appealing job in the eyes of Cassidy.
But that doesn’t mean it makes sense to stay the course with Hiller, even if the Leafs believe 2026-27 is lost. They need a bench boss who won’t destroy McKenna’s confidence and who can build a winning culture that at least carries some momentum into 2027-28, especially if they want to convince Matthews, a 2028 UFA, to sign a contract extension and continue on as a Leaf. And if they want someone who can really grow into the role long term and who already has proven his ability to work with their young guys, the choice very obviously should be current Leafs assistant coach John Gruden.
Gruden was part of Barry Trotz’s staff on some New York Islanders teams that made multiple final-four runs. He was an assistant coach on the 2022-23 Boston Bruins, who broke the NHL’s single-season wins and points records. He led the Leafs’ farm club, the Toronto Marlies, to a Calder Cup championship last season and has worked closely with the likes of Easton Cowan and prospect blueliner Ben Danford.
Handing Gruden the reins would offer a chance to build continuity between the farm and the NHL club, a strategy that has yielded some of the most successful bench bosses of the past decade or more, most notably Jon Cooper with the Tampa Bay Lightning and Jared Bednar with the Colorado Avalanche. Both toiled for years in the AHL and had extreme organizational familiarity by the time they graduated to the big league. The Lightning and Avalanche rank first and fourth in the NHL in wins over the past decade.
Making a coaching change now would be embarrassing. It could make the next coach distrustful of the Leafs’ front office given how quickly they axed Hiller. But the choice shouldn’t even be a difficult one if this franchise cares at all about its pride.
No pushback. No ability to defend their own building from their opponents. If the Leafs as an organization send the message that they’ll tolerate that? The problems go way beyond the man behind the bench.
______
POST SPONSORED BY bet365
