Daily Faceoff is a news site with no direct affiliation to the NHL, or NHLPA

Which teams have underwhelmed so far this season?

Hunter Crowther
Nov 17, 2026, 13:00 EST

PuckPediaDaily Faceoff
Which teams have underwhelmed so far this season?
Credit: Daniel Kucin Jr.

We’re at the quarter-mark of the 2026-27 NHL regular season, and while some teams are right where fans and pundits expected them to be, others have looked underwhelming through their first 20-plus games.

On Tuesday’s episode of Daily Faceoff LIVE, Tyler Yaremchuk and former NHL goaltender Carter Hutton share which teams they believe have underperformed so far this season and what they need to get their seasons back on track.

Tyler Yaremchuk: I was thinking the Carolina Hurricanes might have a tinge of a Stanley Cup hangover, but I thought the Washington Capitals, with everything they did in the offseason, all the signing and spending, the thought was they would be right there with the Hurricanes.

Instead, they’re right there with the New York Rangers, the New York Islanders and all those other teams in the mush of the Eastern Conference. A big reason for that is a bit of a step back from Logan Thompson. Last year, he was fourth among qualified goalies in goals saved above expected, but so far this season, he’s 24th in the league.

This is a team that’s giving up the sixth-highest expected goals at five-on-five. Defensively, they haven’t been what they’ve been in the past, and Thompson has sputtered a little bit to start the season. I have no doubt that they will get things back on track, I still have no doubt that they’re going to find a way to be a playoff team in that Metropolitan Division.

But this Capitals’ start has been a tinge underwhelming.

Carter Hutton: I’m with you, too. I think expectations, when you add Alex Tuch and Jordan Kyrou and all these situations of guys like Ryan Leonard who will play in a better role … you think there would be a bigger step forward.

For me, the Utah Mammoth going 0-3-3 in their last six games … I think last night is a great snapshot into Mammoth hockey. You’re playing the Vancouver Canucks, a team that you have to find a way to earn points against. You tie it up twice in the third period, then you give up a power-play goal with less than five minutes to go.

Their penalty kill and their goaltending is killing them. They’re giving up 3.55 goals against per game, and their PK is at 69%. That’s not good enough if you want to be a playoff team. And their team save percentage, as a unit, is .867. I know Karel Vejmelka has played a lot of minutes in the last few seasons, but they need to find a way to be more consistant with what they have.

You can watch the full segment and the rest of the episode here…

PuckPediaDaily Faceoff