Daily Faceoff is a news site with no direct affiliation to the NHL, or NHLPA

Which NHL team needs a season-saving trade?


Dylan Larkin
Credit: David Kirouac-Imagn Images

The dreaded American Thanksgiving standings juncture rapidly approaches for the NHL. On average, more than three quarters of the playoff picture is set by the final Thursday in November every season.

It’s thus fair to say the time for urgency is now if you’re a team with designs on making the playoffs this season. With that, Roundtable: Which NHL team needs a season-saving trade? 

MATT LARKIN: It’s almost cheating to say the Detroit Red Wings given RFA Simon Edvinsson has just more than a week remaining to sign before he’s ineligible to play in 2026-27. But the Wings are still barely clinging to the playoff periphery despite not having Edvinsson, their second-best defenseman, and Dylan Larkin, their No. 1 center, in the lineup right now. If they have any intention of avoiding an 11th consecutive playoff miss, they need to figure out the deals for their jaded duo ASAP in case the trade returns include players who can bolster their current lineup. 

PAUL PIDUTTI: While the Anaheim Ducks are firmly in the postseason mix in the Western Conference, a team that gives up nearly four goals per game needs to be saved… from themselves. I’m a big believer teams don’t have to play a certain style or be elite at goal prevention to contend. There’s precedent for Stanley Cup-winning teams that can outscore some defensive or goaltending deficiencies. But a team this bad defensively that is so reliant on high-percentage finishing and its power play? I just can’t see the Ducks finding any sustainable success as constructed. Cutter Gauthier only has so many hat tricks in him. Adding a quality, boring veteran defenseman that can penalty kill and stabilize these runaway stallions would be one of several steps needed to dial back the reckless play in Orange County.

STEVEN ELLIS: Hear me out: the Edmonton Oilers. Sure, they’re at the top of the standings. But I worry about the team’s depth beyond Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Evan Bouchard. All three have been truly elite this year and deserve all the love they’re getting. But there isn’t a single other player near the point-per-game mark with forwards like Alex Formenton, Ike Howard and Zach Hyman struggling to produce. Injuries have played a part for a few of these guys, for sure. But God forbid this team loses one of their stars long term. A healthy Matt Savoie could give the team a nice boost, but we still haven’t seen him yet this year. Jake Walman waking up wouldn’t hurt either. Could you imagine how dangerous they’d be if they could get Evgeni Malkin, Dmitri Voronkov, Owen Tippett or even Dylan Larkin or Nikita Kucherov? It wouldn’t make them bullet proof, and there are some cap issues to work through. But, man, wasting another year of No. 97 or 29 can’t be acceptable.

MIKE GOULD: I feel like Matt is fishing for somebody to answer with the Leafs, but I’m going to go in a different direction. The Utah Mammoth haven’t started the 2026-27 season like they wanted, and it has a lot to do with their goaltending. Even after their solid win over the Colorado Avalanche on Wednesday, the Mammoth sit on the Western Conference playoff bubble and remain in desperate need of more stability between the pipes. They went out and paid a first-round pick to get Sebastian Cossa from the Red Wings over the summer, but he hasn’t been particularly good (Colorado game notwithstanding) early in his Utah tenure. Meanwhile, Karel Vejmelka has come in far below expectations with losses in each of his last six games, most recently to the last-place Vancouver Canucks. With Connor Hellebuyck off the market, it’ll be tough for the Mammoth to find an upgrade in goal, but they have to try.

SCOTT MAXWELL: Fine, I’ll take the bait: the Toronto Maple Leafs need to make a trade to turn things around. They’ve lost eight games in a row and 10 of their last 11 and now already sit eight points out of a playoff spot. Considering how last season went, it would make sense to call it a season, retool, collect some younger assets and build towards a better future. However, they don’t have that luxury, especially considering they are without their first-round picks for the next two seasons and Auston Matthews could ask out at any moment if he dislikes the team’s direction. The Leafs must salvage the season as best they can and, at the very least, devalue their first-round pick as much as possible. Given their blueline’s current state, defense is the most obvious problem to fix with a trade. While the market isn’t too strong yet (aside from Edvinsson), perhaps Vince Dunn or Erik Karlsson could be of help as the trade deadline gets closer. But will it be too late by the time players of that caliber are available?

ANTHONY TRUDEAU: ‘Season-saving’ might be a stretch for a first-place team, but I’d love to see the Minnesota Wild nab just one more impact forward amid their fast start. Even with Blake Coleman, Michael McCarron, and Bobby Brink playing well as a hardworking, makeshift second line, coach John Hynes’s decision to load up a Kaprizov-Eriksson Ek-Boldy first unit still leaves Minnesota awfully top-heavy, especially as veteran power forward Ryan Hartman struggles to make an impact. A huge swing might not be in the budget, but adding Rickard Rakell or the aforementioned Tippett to play off Max Shabanov and Danila Yurov would really solidify the Wild’s top nine. A bit more depth up front could help Minnesota hold a Central Division lead it has built with star power and top-tier goaltending.

MATT LARKIN: Is it too late to change my answer to the Washington Capitals? Get on the horn for Edvinsson!

_____

DAILY FACEOFF NEWSLETTER

Your daily hockey fix, delivered straight to your inbox. Get connected to every NHL storyline with breaking news, lineup updates, trade buzz, and expert analysis—delivered every morning. Sign up for the Daily Faceoff newsletter and don’t miss a beat!

Recently by Daily Faceoff

How we would fix the Chicago Blackhawks
If you could take over as GM of any NHL team, whom would you pick?
Which Canadian teams will make the 2026-27 Stanley Cup playoffs?
Who will be the first NHL coach fired in 2026-27?